Avoiding pinning an RDS Proxy - Amazon Relational Database Service
What RDS Proxy tracks for RDS for SQL Server databasesWhat RDS Proxy tracks for RDS for MariaDB and RDS for MySQL databasesMinimizing pinningConditions that cause pinning for all engine familiesConditions that cause pinning for RDS for Microsoft SQL ServerConditions that cause pinning for RDS for MariaDB and RDS for MySQLConditions that cause pinning for RDS for PostgreSQL

Avoiding pinning an RDS Proxy

Multiplexing is more efficient when database requests don't rely on state information from previous requests. In that case, RDS Proxy can reuse a connection at the conclusion of each transaction. Examples of such state information include most variables and configuration parameters that you can change through SET or SELECT statements. SQL transactions on a client connection can multiplex between underlying database connections by default.

Your connections to the proxy can enter a state known as pinning. When a connection is pinned, each later transaction uses the same underlying database connection until the session ends. Other client connections also can't reuse that database connection until the session ends. The session ends when the client connection is dropped.

RDS Proxy automatically pins a client connection to a specific DB connection when it detects a session state change that isn't appropriate for other sessions. Pinning reduces the effectiveness of connection reuse. If all or almost all of your connections experience pinning, consider modifying your application code or workload to reduce the conditions that cause the pinning.

For example, your application changes a session variable or configuration parameter. In this case, later statements can rely on the new variable or parameter to be in effect. Thus, when RDS Proxy processes requests to change session variables or configuration settings, it pins that session to the DB connection. That way, the session state remains in effect for all later transactions in the same session.

For some database engines, this rule doesn't apply to all parameters that you can set. RDS Proxy tracks certain statements and variables. Thus, RDS Proxy doesn't pin the session when you modify them. In this case, RDS Proxy only reuses the connection for other sessions that have the same values for those settings. For details about what RDS Proxy tracks for a database engine, see the following:

What RDS Proxy tracks for RDS for SQL Server databases

Following are the SQL Server statements that RDS Proxy tracks:

  • USE

  • SET ANSI_NULLS

  • SET ANSI_PADDING

  • SET ANSI_WARNINGS

  • SET ARITHABORT

  • SET CONCAT_NULL_YIELDS_NULL

  • SET CURSOR_CLOSE_ON_COMMIT

  • SET DATEFIRST

  • SET DATEFORMAT

  • SET LANGUAGE

  • SET LOCK_TIMEOUT

  • SET NUMERIC_ROUNDABORT

  • SET QUOTED_IDENTIFIER

  • SET TEXTSIZE

  • SET TRANSACTION ISOLATION LEVEL

What RDS Proxy tracks for RDS for MariaDB and RDS for MySQL databases

Following are the MariaDB and MySQL statements that RDS Proxy tracks:

  • DROP DATABASE

  • DROP SCHEMA

  • USE

Following are the MySQL and MariaDB variables that RDS Proxy tracks:

  • AUTOCOMMIT

  • AUTO_INCREMENT_INCREMENT

  • CHARACTER SET (or CHAR SET)

  • CHARACTER_SET_CLIENT

  • CHARACTER_SET_DATABASE

  • CHARACTER_SET_FILESYSTEM

  • CHARACTER_SET_CONNECTION

  • CHARACTER_SET_RESULTS

  • CHARACTER_SET_SERVER

  • COLLATION_CONNECTION

  • COLLATION_DATABASE

  • COLLATION_SERVER

  • INTERACTIVE_TIMEOUT

  • NAMES

  • NET_WRITE_TIMEOUT

  • QUERY_CACHE_TYPE

  • SESSION_TRACK_SCHEMA

  • SQL_MODE

  • TIME_ZONE

  • TRANSACTION_ISOLATION (or TX_ISOLATION)

  • TRANSACTION_READ_ONLY (or TX_READ_ONLY)

  • WAIT_TIMEOUT

Minimizing pinning

Performance tuning for RDS Proxy involves trying to maximize transaction-level connection reuse (multiplexing) by minimizing pinning.

You can minimize pinning by doing the following:

  • Avoid unnecessary database requests that might cause pinning.

  • Set variables and configuration settings consistently across all connections. That way, later sessions are more likely to reuse connections that have those particular settings.

    However, for PostgreSQL setting a variable leads to session pinning.

  • For a MySQL engine family database, apply a session pinning filter to the proxy. You can exempt certain kinds of operations from pinning the session if you know that doing so doesn't affect the correct operation of your application.

  • See how frequently pinning occurs by monitoring the Amazon CloudWatch metric DatabaseConnectionsCurrentlySessionPinned. For information about this and other CloudWatch metrics, see Monitoring RDS Proxy metrics with Amazon CloudWatch.

  • If you use SET statements to perform identical initialization for each client connection, you can do so while preserving transaction-level multiplexing. In this case, you move the statements that set up the initial session state into the initialization query used by a proxy. This property is a string containing one or more SQL statements, separated by semicolons.

    For example, you can define an initialization query for a proxy that sets certain configuration parameters. Then, RDS Proxy applies those settings whenever it sets up a new connection for that proxy. You can remove the corresponding SET statements from your application code, so that they don't interfere with transaction-level multiplexing.

    For metrics about how often pinning occurs for a proxy, see Monitoring RDS Proxy metrics with Amazon CloudWatch.

Conditions that cause pinning for all engine families

The proxy pins the session to the current connection in the following situations where multiplexing might cause unexpected behavior:

  • Any statement with a text size greater than 16 KB causes the proxy to pin the session.

Conditions that cause pinning for RDS for Microsoft SQL Server

For RDS for SQL Server, the following interactions also cause pinning:

  • Using multiple active result sets (MARS). For information about MARS, see the SQL Server documentation.

  • Using distributed transaction coordinator (DTC) communication.

  • Creating temporary tables, transactions, cursors, or prepared statements.

  • Using the following SET statements:

    • SET ANSI_DEFAULTS

    • SET ANSI_NULL_DFLT

    • SET ARITHIGNORE

    • SET DEADLOCK_PRIORITY

    • SET FIPS_FLAGGER

    • SET FMTONLY

    • SET FORCEPLAN

    • SET IDENTITY_INSERT

    • SET NOCOUNT

    • SET NOEXEC

    • SET OFFSETS

    • SET PARSEONLY

    • SET QUERY_GOVERNOR_COST_LIMIT

    • SET REMOTE_PROC_TRANSACTIONS

    • SET ROWCOUNT

    • SET SHOWPLAN_ALL, SHOWPLAN_TEXT, and SHOWPLAN_XML

    • SET STATISTICS

    • SET XACT_ABORT

Conditions that cause pinning for RDS for MariaDB and RDS for MySQL

For MariaDB and MySQL, the following interactions also cause pinning:

  • Explicit table lock statements LOCK TABLE, LOCK TABLES, or FLUSH TABLES WITH READ LOCK cause the proxy to pin the session.

  • Creating named locks by using GET_LOCK causes the proxy to pin the session.

  • Setting a user variable or a system variable (with some exceptions) causes the proxy to pin the session. If this situation reduces your connection reuse too much, then choose for SET operations to not cause pinning. For information about how to do so by setting the session pinning filters property, see Creating an RDS Proxy and Modifying RDS Proxy.

  • Creating a temporary table causes the proxy to pin the session. That way, the contents of the temporary table are preserved throughout the session regardless of transaction boundaries.

  • Calling the ROW_COUNT and FOUND_ROWS functions sometimes causes pinning.

  • Prepared statements cause the proxy to pin the session. This rule applies whether the prepared statement uses SQL text or the binary protocol.

  • RDS Proxy does not pin connections when you use SET LOCAL.

  • Calling stored procedures and stored functions doesn't cause pinning. RDS Proxy doesn't detect any session state changes resulting from such calls. Make sure that your application doesn't change session state inside stored routines if you rely on that session state to persist across transactions. For example, RDS Proxy isn't currently compatible with a stored procedure that creates a temporary table that persists across all transactions.

If you have expert knowledge about your application behavior, you can skip the pinning behavior for certain application statements. To do so, choose the Session pinning filters option when creating the proxy. Currently, you can opt out of session pinning for setting session variables and configuration settings.

Conditions that cause pinning for RDS for PostgreSQL

For PostgreSQL, the following interactions also cause pinning:

  • Using SET commands.

  • Using PREPARE, DISCARD, DEALLOCATE, or EXECUTE commands to manage prepared statements.

  • Creating temporary sequences, tables, or views.

  • Declaring cursors.

  • Discarding the session state.

  • Listening on a notification channel.

  • Loading a library module such as auto_explain.

  • Manipulating sequences using functions such as nextval and setval.

  • Interacting with locks using functions such as pg_advisory_lock and pg_try_advisory_lock.

    Note

    RDS Proxy does not pin on transaction level advisory locks, specifically pg_advisory_xact_lock, pg_advisory_xact_lock_shared, pg_try_advisory_xact_lock, and pg_try_advisory_xact_lock_shared.

  • Setting a parameter, or resetting a parameter to its default. Specifically, using SET and set_config commands to assign default values to session variables.

  • Calling stored procedures and stored functions doesn't cause pinning. RDS Proxy doesn't detect any session state changes resulting from such calls. Make sure that your application doesn't change session state inside stored routines if you rely on that session state to persist across transactions. For example, RDS Proxy isn't currently compatible with a stored procedure that creates a temporary table that persists across all transactions.