Types of Macie findings - Amazon Macie
Types of policy findingsTypes of sensitive data findings

Types of Macie findings

Amazon Macie generates two categories of findings: policy findings and sensitive data findings. A policy finding is a detailed report of a potential policy violation or issue with the security or privacy of an Amazon Simple Storage Service (Amazon S3) general purpose bucket. Macie generates policy findings as part of its ongoing activities to evaluate and monitor your general purpose buckets for security and access control. A sensitive data finding is a detailed report of sensitive data that Macie detected in an S3 object. Macie generates sensitive data findings as part of the activities that it performs when you run sensitive data discovery jobs or it performs automated sensitive data discovery.

Within each category, there are specific types. A finding's type provides insight into the nature of the issue or sensitive data that Macie found. A finding's details provide a severity rating, information about the affected resource, and additional information, such as when and how Macie found the issue or sensitive data. The severity and details of each finding vary depending on the type and nature of the finding.

Tip

To explore and learn about the different categories and types of findings that Macie can generate, create sample findings. Sample findings use example data and placeholder values to demonstrate the kinds of information that each type of finding might contain.

Types of policy findings

Amazon Macie generates a policy finding when the policies or settings for an S3 general purpose bucket are changed in a way that reduces the security or privacy of the bucket and the bucket's objects. For information about how Macie detects these changes, see How Macie monitors Amazon S3 data security.

Macie generates a policy finding only if the change occurs after you enable Macie for your AWS account. For example, if block public access settings are disabled for an S3 bucket after you enable Macie, Macie generates a Policy:IAMUser/S3BlockPublicAccessDisabled finding for the bucket. If block public access settings were disabled for a bucket when you enabled Macie and they continue to be disabled, Macie doesn't generate a Policy:IAMUser/S3BlockPublicAccessDisabled finding for the bucket.

If Macie detects a subsequent occurrence of an existing policy finding, Macie updates the existing finding by adding details about the subsequent occurrence and incrementing the count of occurrences. Macie stores policy findings for 90 days.

Macie can generate the following types of policy findings for an S3 general purpose bucket.

Policy:IAMUser/S3BlockPublicAccessDisabled

All bucket-level block public access settings were disabled for the bucket. Access to the bucket is controlled by the block public access settings for the account, access control lists (ACLs), and the bucket policy for the bucket.

To learn about block public access settings for S3 buckets, see Blocking public access to your Amazon S3 storage in the Amazon Simple Storage Service User Guide.

Policy:IAMUser/S3BucketEncryptionDisabled

Default encryption settings for the bucket were reset to default Amazon S3 encryption behavior, which is to encrypt new objects automatically with an Amazon S3 managed key.

Starting January 5, 2023, Amazon S3 automatically applies server-side encryption with Amazon S3 managed keys (SSE-S3) as the base level of encryption for objects that are added to buckets. You can optionally configure a bucket's default encryption settings to instead use server-side encryption with an AWS KMS key (SSE-KMS) or dual-layer server-side encryption with an AWS KMS key (DSSE-KMS). To learn about default encryption settings and options for S3 buckets, see Setting default server-side encryption behavior for S3 buckets in the Amazon Simple Storage Service User Guide.

If Macie generated this type of finding prior to January 5, 2023, the finding indicates that default encryption settings were disabled for the affected bucket. This meant that the bucket’s settings didn’t specify default server-side encryption behavior for new objects. The ability to disable default encryption settings for a bucket is no longer supported by Amazon S3.

Policy:IAMUser/S3BucketPublic

An ACL or bucket policy for the bucket was changed to allow access by anonymous users or all authenticated AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM) identities.

To learn about ACLs and bucket policies for S3 buckets, see Access control in the Amazon Simple Storage Service User Guide.

Policy:IAMUser/S3BucketReplicatedExternally

Replication was enabled and configured to replicate objects from the bucket to a bucket for an AWS account that's external to (not part of) your organization. An organization is a set of Macie accounts that are centrally managed as a group of related accounts through AWS Organizations or by Macie invitation.

Under certain conditions, Macie might generate this type of finding for a bucket that isn’t configured to replicate objects to a bucket for an external AWS account. This can occur if the destination bucket was created in a different AWS Region during the preceding 24 hours, after Macie retrieved bucket and object metadata from Amazon S3 as part of the daily refresh cycle. To investigate the finding, start by refreshing your inventory data. Then review the bucket’s details. The details indicate whether the bucket is configured to replicate objects to other buckets. If the bucket is configured to do this, the details include the account ID for each account that owns a destination bucket.

To learn about replication settings for S3 buckets, see Replicating objects in the Amazon Simple Storage Service User Guide.

Policy:IAMUser/S3BucketSharedExternally

An ACL or bucket policy for the bucket was changed to allow the bucket to be shared with an AWS account that's external to (not part of) your organization. An organization is a set of Macie accounts that are centrally managed as a group of related accounts through AWS Organizations or by Macie invitation.

In certain cases, Macie might generate this type of finding for a bucket that isn’t shared with an external AWS account. This can occur if Macie isn’t able to fully evaluate the relationship between the Principal element in the bucket’s policy and certain AWS global condition context keys or Amazon S3 condition keys in the Condition element of the policy. The applicable condition keys are: aws:PrincipalAccount, aws:PrincipalArn, aws:PrincipalOrgID, aws:PrincipalOrgPaths, aws:PrincipalTag, aws:PrincipalType, aws:SourceAccount, aws:SourceArn, aws:SourceIp, aws:SourceOrgID, aws:SourceOrgPaths, aws:SourceVpc, aws:SourceVpce, aws:userid, s3:DataAccessPointAccount, and s3:DataAccessPointArn. We recommend that you review the bucket’s policy to determine whether this access is intended and safe.

To learn about ACLs and bucket policies for S3 buckets, see Access control in the Amazon Simple Storage Service User Guide.

Policy:IAMUser/S3BucketSharedWithCloudFront

The bucket policy for the bucket was changed to allow the bucket to be shared with an Amazon CloudFront origin access identity (OAI), a CloudFront origin access control (OAC), or both a CloudFront OAI and a CloudFront OAC. A CloudFront OAI or OAC allows users to access a bucket's objects through one or more specified CloudFront distributions.

To learn about CloudFront OAIs and OACs, see Restricting access to an Amazon S3 origin in the Amazon CloudFront Developer Guide.

Note

In certain cases, Macie generates a Policy:IAMUser/S3BucketSharedExternally finding instead of a Policy:IAMUser/S3BucketSharedWithCloudFront finding for a bucket. These cases are:

  • The bucket is shared with an AWS account that's external to your organization, in addition to a CloudFront OAI or OAC.

  • The bucket's policy specifies a canonical user ID, instead of the Amazon Resource Name (ARN), of a CloudFront OAI.

This produces a higher severity policy finding for the bucket.

Types of sensitive data findings

Amazon Macie generates a sensitive data finding when it detects sensitive data in an S3 object that it analyzes to discover sensitive data. This includes analysis that Macie performs when you run a sensitive data discovery job or it performs automated sensitive data discovery.

For example, if you create and run a sensitive data discovery job and Macie detects bank account numbers in an S3 object, Macie generates a SensitiveData:S3Object/Financial finding for the object. Similarly, if Macie detects bank account numbers in an S3 object that it analyzes during an automated sensitive data discovery cycle, Macie generates a SensitiveData:S3Object/Financial finding for the object.

If Macie detects sensitive data in the same S3 object during a subsequent job run or automated sensitive data discovery cycle, Macie generates a new sensitive data finding for the object. Unlike policy findings, all sensitive data findings are treated as new (unique). Macie stores sensitive data findings for 90 days.

Macie can generate the following types of sensitive data findings for an S3 object.

SensitiveData:S3Object/Credentials

The object contains sensitive credentials data, such as AWS secret access keys or private keys.

SensitiveData:S3Object/CustomIdentifier

The object contains text that matches the detection criteria of one or more custom data identifiers. The object might contain more than one type of sensitive data.

SensitiveData:S3Object/Financial

The object contains sensitive financial information, such as bank account numbers or credit card numbers.

SensitiveData:S3Object/Multiple

The object contains more than one category of sensitive data—any combination of credentials data, financial information, personal information, or text that matches the detection criteria of one or more custom data identifiers.

SensitiveData:S3Object/Personal

The object contains sensitive personal information—personally identifiable information (PII) such as passport numbers or driver's license identification numbers, personal health information (PHI) such as health insurance or medical identification numbers, or a combination of PII and PHI.

For information about the types of sensitive data that Macie can detect using built-in criteria and techniques, see Using managed data identifiers. For information about the types of S3 objects that Macie can analyze, see Supported storage classes and formats.